Captain's Catch: Building the Perfect Seafood Medley

Some dogs and cats are fish fanatics, and for them we built Captain's Catch — a freeze-dried seafood medley that brings the best of the ocean into one crunchy, shareable reward. Think of it as a variety pack for the fish-obsessed. Here is the philosophy behind the blend.

Why a medley?

Feeding a single fish is great, but rotating proteins gives pets a wider range of flavors and nutrients — and keeps enthusiasm high. A medley lets you deliver that variety in every handful without opening four different bags. It is also a low-stakes way to discover which fish your pet loves most before you commit to a full bag of one.

The ocean lineup

Freeze-dried seafood shines because the cold process locks in the delicate omega-3 fatty acids that make fish so good for skin, coat, and joints. Small whole fish like minnows and the flakes from salmon bring different textures and flavor intensities, while other small fish round out the mix. For a deeper dive on the little-fish debate, see anchovies vs. sardines.

Great for dogs AND cats

Here is the fun part: seafood is a rare treat that both species go wild for, which makes Captain's Catch a natural fit for multi-pet households. Cats in particular respond to the intense aroma of freeze-dried fish — more on that in our complete cat treat guide. One medley, one happy household.

How to serve it

Use it as a high-value training reward, a food topper crumbled over meals, or an anytime snack. Because it is freeze-dried, it is shelf-stable and mess-free — perfect for tossing in the bag before a road trip. Keep servings within about 10% of daily calories.

Frequently asked questions

Is fish good for dogs and cats? Yes — fish provides high-quality protein and omega-3s that support skin, coat, and joint health. As always, feed treats in moderation.

Can I feed Captain's Catch to both my dog and cat? Absolutely. It is designed as a hybrid, dog-and-cat treat. Adjust portion size to each pet.

Does freeze-dried fish smell strong? To pets, gloriously so — that aroma is a big part of the appeal. To humans it is a mild, clean fish scent.

Set sail with the whole crew

If your household has a fish lover (or four), the medley is calling. Scoop up Captain's Catch and let dogs and cats share the ocean's best.